This fact is evidenced by the prevailing condition of spiritual deadness and insensitivity, the drift to worldliness, the decline in deep spirituality, the loss of evangelistic zeal, and the increasing dependence on tradition, man-rule, and intellectual understanding of the doctrine. God is not coming for a defeated, divided, spiritually ragged, powerless church. The Assemblies of God considers itself a large fellowship rather than a denomination. To preach the true Gospel of the Kingdom of God (Mark 1:14; Matthew 24:14; Ezekiel 3 and 33), and the name of Jesus Christ (Acts 8:12) to all nations as a witness. God no longer tolerates these dark conditions. No conclusive motive for the mass murder was reached, though police investigated religious issues as potential motives for the shooting [19][20][21]. Classroom is the educational resource for people of all ages. Confession and Freedom From Specific Cult/Occult Strongholds (includes WCG, PCG & all offshoots). According to LCG beliefs, the Godhead is comprised of just two beings: God the Father, the Supreme Being, and Jesus Christ, the Son, the savior of all mankind and the acting head of the church. We also publish an extensive, 24-course Bible study programavailable in English, Spanish, and Frenchthat takes subscribers through an extensive review of prophecy, biblical doctrines, and Christian practice. Members of the Evangelical Lutheran Church in America (a mainline denomination), the Lutheran Church-Missouri Synod (an evangelical denomination) and the United Methodist Church (the largest mainline church) are all more than 90% white. This article was published in the Milwaukee Journal Sentinel on March 20, 2005 about the Living Church of God shooting spree. These men were the very first Evangelists of the WCG. Whether youre studying times tables or applying to college, Classroom has the answers. It is time for every one of Gods children to hear and obey, in fullness, Gods precious Word. Also read the book, Jesus Christ IS God by Robert L. Sumner, which is one of most comprehensive works defending the Deity of Christ. We sponsor the global broadcast of the Tomorrows World television programa weekly half-hour telecast explaining the end-time prophecies of the Bible, announcing the good news of the Kingdom of God, and spreading the teachings of Jesus Christ. Living Word Church of God is working in Religion, Churches activities. God is a loving, kind, merciful being who wants to share His magnificent existence by reproducing Himself through man. The burdens that will be expected of the member is never shown upfront until they join the organization. The Living Church of God proclaims to the world the good news of Jesus Christ's coming Kingdom ( Matthew 24:14; Mark 16:15 ), and blows a bold "warning trumpet" of God's impending judgment, calling for repentance and spiritual change ( Matthew 24:21; Isaiah 58:1; Ezekiel 33 ). From the early to mid-1950s, and again in 1960, he was assigned by Armstrong to live in Britain to form congregations for the Church there. LCGs teachings are in direct conflict with the gospel of grace as presented in the N.T., especially in the Epistles of Paul. While many other Christian denominations believe the Holy Spirit is a third member of the Godhead, the LCG doctrine states that the Holy Spirit is the essence and power of God and not an actual being. A new splinter of LCG, Church of God Assembly, was formed in September 2020 after Sheldon Monson (minister in LCG) was fired by Gerald Weston. While LCG will say there are branches to the true church today (referring to WCG splinters that teach HWAs dogma and which call themselves churches of God), in Merediths booklet, Where is Gods True Church Today? he asks the reader, How can you recognize Gods true Church? Read our research on: Congress | Economy | Gender. A description of both are listed on our Links. ), LCG teaches that there is only one true gospel which is about the Kingdom of God, but this gospel is centered on Gods government, to be enforced upon the entire world when Christ returns, and which members will have a big part in. (Read: Did Herbert Armstrong Set Dates? The Living Church of God practices original Christianity, straight from the Bible. American. Muslims (8.7) and Jehovahs Witnesses (8.6) are close behind in terms of diversity, as no racial or ethnic group makes up more than 40% of either group. In May 2006, LCG's media department reported that the show was accessible to nearly 78 million American households, or 71 percent of the American television market.[12]. Summer Educational Program camps (S. E. P.). Following Meredith's graduation from Ambassador College in Pasadena, California in June 1952, he was assigned by Herbert W. Armstrong (Pastor General of the Worldwide Church of God) to set up and pastor WCG congregations in Portland, Oregon; San Diego, California; and Seattle and Tacoma, Washington. Living Youth Camp is LCGs camp for their youth and is patterned after HWAs Summer Educational Program camps (S. E. P.). Available in English, Spanish, French, and several other languages, the "Tomorrow's World" program continues the Work of God to reach the world with the truth. 6,000,000+ members [1] The Church of God (Cleveland, Tennessee) is a Holiness Pentecostal Christian denomination, with headquarters in Cleveland, Tennessee. Worldwide Church of God, Adventist church founded in 1933 as the Radio Church of God by Herbert W. Armstrong (1892-1986), an American newspaper advertising designer. They state that the Law God gave the Israelites is binding on New Testament Christians as well. This is the final fulfillment of the Gospel of Jesus Christthe ultimate Good Newsthat man can be born into the God Kingdom, the God-level of existence.8 [bolding ours], LCG teaches that Jesus was not God while on earth, but became God at His resurrection. Meredith affirmed this law-keeping teaching early on in his 1956 booklet, Is Obedience to God Required for Salvation? [14] Additionally, the church operates a Tomorrow's World website.[15]. 3.) We strive to practice original Christianity as taught and practiced by Jesus Christ and the original Apostles, including observance of the seventh-day Sabbath and annual Holy Days. Click the button below to visit our headquarters site. All answers to reader questions are provided for informational purposes only. And the Spirit and the bride say, Come. And let him that heareth say, Come. The sight of the saints of God has never failed to bring relief to a fellow pilgrim. A passion for the truth and the Work of Jesus Christ, The Sevenfold Commission of the Living Church of God, Living Church of God: 2015 Consolidated Financial Statements, Living Church of God: 2016 Consolidated Financial Statements, Living Church of God: 2017 Consolidated Financial Statements, Living Church of God: 2018 Consolidated Financial Statements, Living Church of God: 2019 Consolidated Financial Statements, Living Church of God: 2020 Consolidated Financial Statements, Living Church of God: 2021 Consolidated Financial Statements. C. Paul Meredith was appointed director of the Ambassador College Bible Correspondence Course in 1954 by Herbert W. Armstrong. 31, 33,1996. He is coming for a glorious church, not having spot, or wrinkle, or any such thing. However, when overseeing the ministry during the 1960s, he began to gain a reputation for being too strict in his application of Church rules and regulations. We must never forget that Christs teaching was not primarily about Himself, but was a message about the coming world government which He will soon set up here on this earth. (January 16, 2005 Dear Brethren and Co-Workers letter by R. Meredith) 8 Your Ultimate Destiny by Roderick C. Meredith, pp. In the aftermath of the Azusa St. Revival, the demand for denominational organization became clear to many when founded Christian churches mostly denied Pentecostal followers. Dr. Andrew Farley shows you why so many Christians today are feeling weighed down and burned out in this 8-day reading plan. Meredith said the true church is to first: preach this gospel of the Kingdom and second: to preach the true name of Jesus Christ.7 Yet, Meredith preached another gospel (Galatians 1:6-7), and the Jesus he preached is a false Jesus. (Many excellent letters from 2005), I Struggled Mentally and Had to Unlearn and Relearn After LCG (2022), Why Im Leaving Living Church of God (2021), Living Church of God Claiming to Be a Charity (2021) [includes good reply], MeredithAnother Evil Armstrong-Clone Finally Departs (2017), You Saved Me From Living Church of God (2016), Feel Completely Normal Again After Leaving Living Church of God (2015), I Was Able to Exit From the Cultic Teachings of Living Church of God (2011), Didnt Feel Easy With Living Church of Gods Preaching and Focus (2011), True Church Teaching of Roderick Meredith (2010), Spared From Living Church of God After Finding ESN Site (2009), Almost Made a Very Bad Mistake with LCG (2004). This Church is "living" because we have prophets who continue to give us the word of the Lord that is needed for our time. It was formed as a series of major doctrinal changes were introduced in the Worldwide Church of God (WCG, originally incorporated as the Radio Church of God) after Armstrong's death in 1986. Now traditionally at least the answer to that question of why did Christianity triumph in the Roman world was answered very simply. And much more! On February 27, 2007, LCG launched Living University, a nonprofit, online (distance-learning) institution. 1/19/98: My Worldwide Church of God Horror story: My parents became interested in the Worldwide Church of God in the mid-1960s. - Mark 16:15. There are many different Christian denominations that use the name Church of God, but the largest, with more than 7 million members worldwide, is the Church of God with headquarters in Cleveland, Tenn. church of god, christians, denominations, beliefs, Prayer Changes Your Brain in 4 Amazing Ways, Can Prayer Heal You? In 2006, Charles Bryce (whom Meredith had appointed head of Church administration) left and formed Enduring Church of God. The telecast also airs in Russian, German and other languages in translation on satellites across the globe, and is available via cable and the Internet. The Holy Spirit also empowers believers . The Living Church of God is headquartered in Charlotte, North Carolina. Among people with no religious affiliation, those whose religion is nothing in particular (score of 6.9 on the index) are more diverse than atheists (4.7) and agnostics (4.5). "The Living Church of God (LCG) is one of the church groups formed by followers of the teachings of the late Herbert W. Armstrong. About History COG Heritage In Memory Campus Tour BYLAWS Numbers, Facts and Trends Shaping Your World, Size & Demographic Characteristics of Religious Groups, Q&A: The Muslim-Christian education gap in sub-Saharan Africa, Muslims in sub-Saharan Africa are twice as likely as Christians to have no formal education, How Religious Groups Differ in Educational Attainment, 60% of Americans Would Be Uncomfortable With Provider Relying on AI in Their Own Health Care, Gender pay gap in U.S. hasnt changed much in two decades. Ephesians 5:27. The AC Bible Correspondence Course was used in recruiting others into HWAs organization. The most well-known of Armstrong's teachings is that of Anglo-Israelism. He finally brings the reader to the point of thinking, Yes! Living Church of God members were known to refer to Rod Meredith as Gods anointed. (Refer to March 21 letter My Experience With Global and Living Church of God Was a Horrible One in the section on Letters About the Shooting Spree) Members of exclusive groups often give their leaders titles that glorify them. The soul of Jonathan was knit with the soul of David. Churches by Denomination. However, if you can't find local churches within that denomination, ones who. More than 550 half-hour programs produced as of April 2017, Never asks for donations; offers free DVDs, CDs, booklets on every program, Freely you havereceived; freely give (Matthew 10:8), Programs focus on Bible prophecy, current events and the meaning and purpose of life, More than 3million pieces of literature have been sent free to viewers, requestors as a result of the, More than 31million free Tomorrows World magazines have been distributed, Free literature is also available in Spanish, French, German, Dutch, Chinese, Russian, others, Estimated 240,000 viewers per week in North America, Available over-the-air or on cable to 118million North American households, Network/Superstation airings include CW-PLUS, GOSPEL, and CNLTV (Russia). Please note that this advice is generic and not specific to any individual. Director of Public Relations The Living Church of God (LCG) is one of several groups that formed after the death of Herbert W. Armstrong, when major doctrinal changes (causing turmoil and divisions) were occurring in the former Worldwide Church of God (WCG) during the 1990s. The Church of God (Philippines), is a group of godly believers who bonded themselves together in the Philadelphian spirit of Revelation 3:7, 8 (on the first day of the Sacred year in 2016), to be freed from political and corporate controls, in order to pursue and practice godly love, more and purer biblical truths; and to be able to carry out a Be more. We looked at 30groups including Protestant denominations, other religious groups and three subsets of people who are religiously unaffiliated based on a methodology used in our 2014 Pew Research Center report on global religious diversity. (Trust Christs Leadership, taped sermon by RCM, July 6, 1996.) The church now claims over 6,000 members worldwide. The Living Church of God proclaims to the world the good news of Jesus Christs coming Kingdom (Matthew 24:14; Mark 16:15), and blows a bold warning trumpet of Gods impending judgment, calling for repentance and spiritual change (Matthew 24:21; Isaiah 58:1; Ezekiel 33). If you require more immediate assistance please visit our Contact Us page. We have more than 239 ministers serving over 401 congregations around the globe. The Abundant Grace Church of the Living God is a non-denominational church that was formed in the summer of 2014. Since the college was not accredited by any agency recognized by the U.S. Department of Education, getting a theological degree from LCGs Living University was not worth the paper it was printed on. Ratzmann then took his own life, police said.. Members observe the biblical Sabbath starting on Fridays at sundown. In 2003, he left San Diego and moved his LCG headquarters to its present location in Charlotte, North Carolina. The Living Church of God is devoted to that mission. Some believe that groups such as the DeMolays are feeder groups for the Masons (being groomed for potential membership in Masonry and the Eastern Star when they reach adulthood. Hidden Secrets of the Eastern Star by Cathy Burns) Could Dr. C. Paul Meredith (Roderick Merediths uncle) perhaps have been a Mason himself? "A popular elder and former pastor of the Living Church of God, Karl Beyersdorfer, 73, took his own life May 27, 2016, at his home in Joplin, Mo. Headquarters (and what they say to do) is always correlated with God. Killings Shed Light on Church. Read: Roderick Meredith Wife Dies. Aaron was glad when he saw Moses. To use our advanced search functionality (to search for terms in specific content), please use syntax such as the following examples: The Tomorrows World telecast proclaims the gospel of the soon-coming Kingdom of God, when JesusChrist will reign on earth and there will be harmony, unity and love among peoples of all races,ethnicities and nationalities. WCG was known for decades as a destructive, authoritarian religious group, which claimed to be the "one and only true Church of God" with Herbert Armstrong considered "God's apostle" who was said to have received revelation from God. WCG was known for decades as a destructive, authoritarian religious group, which claimed to be the one and only true Church of God with Herbert Armstrong considered Gods apostle who was said to have received revelation from God. But this group may be less diverse because Asian-American Buddhists may have been underrepresented since the survey was conducted in only English and Spanish, and not in any Asian languages. It was God's will, of course, but I think we can probably find . The Assemblies of God was founded in 1914 in Hot Springs, Arkansas, with 300 people at the founding convention. When Roderick Merediths wife Sheryl died of cancer, he asked for money instead of flowers to be sent to LCG. [6] An independent auditor specializing in non-profits reported that the church's income for 2010 was over US$14.3 million. 02 Mar 2023 04:39:56 1.1K views, 59 likes, 7 loves, 2 comments, 2 shares, Facebook Watch Videos from : #__ - . 6 General Catalog, Living University, 2013-2014 7 Do You Believe the True Gospel? In addition to the television program and magazine, the Living Church of God publishes an extensive collection of resources, in print and online, also made freely available to all. And whosoever will, let him take the water of life freely. Adeboye and other "men of God" must really be WHEREY For caging your brain in church, religion is truly a disaster! Expose` Material on Roderick Meredith as a Minister: The Broadway to Armageddon by William B. Hinson (book in PDF; search for Roderick Merediths name), Herbert Armstrongs Tangled Web by David Robinson (book is available PDF; search for Roderick Merediths name), Testimonies: (Names have been changed) Testimonies by Former Members of Living Church of God, Eight Dead in Living Church of God Shooting Spree! 2 of the Robert Gerringer Letter (search for the word Meredith). . LCG's founder and Presiding Evangelist was, until his death, Roderick C. Meredith (June 21, 1930 May 18, 2017). In late 2012, member Bob Thiel left and formed the Continuing Church of God. Seven people, including the churchs minister and his teenage son, were killed and four others wounded. Living Church of God is an offshoot of Worldwide Church of God (WCG), founded in 1934 by Herbert W. Armstrong (HWA). Living Word Church of God is located in Ashland City, Tennessee. A denomination with solid teaching, and a clear understanding of what qualifies as bad teaching, is vital. Anthon Jackson is a writer and photographer. From the magazine's inception in 1999 through to May 2007, 8.3 million copies were produced. (It disbanded after his death in 2008.) Learn more about God the Mother through all of the studies below. To preach the end-time prophecies and to warn the English-speaking nations and all the world of the coming Great Tribulation (Matthew 24:21). After baptism and confirmation, members are expected to continue to grow in the "grace and knowledge of God" until the day of salvation, which followers believe will one day happen at the same time as bodily resurrection. To receive the latest in Church of God and other news, sign up to receive Faith News (faithnews.cc). The gospel or truth that LCG teaches is totally lacking in the knowledge of redeeming grace; instead it places the focus on striving to obey the Mosaic Law (which Meredith insisted is still binding on Christians). By contrast, roughly eight-in-ten atheists (78%) and agnostics (79%) are white. Religion tells us, "Do more. Testimony of Jesus Christ The third reason why we are the only true Church is that we have the revealed truth about the nature of God and our relationship to Him, and we therefore have a unique testimony of Jesus Christ. Even Christians upon their first meeting have the witness of the Spirit that they have met one who, with themselves, is a partaker of the common salvation. From Matthew 16:1318 and 1 Corinthians 12:1227, Pastor Chuck illustrates how each Christian member . Mr. Weston was ordained a minister of Jesus Christ in 1971 and has served congregations throughout the United States, Canada and Europe. Meredith was the youngest of the newly ordained men and the fifth to be ordained. About Us. We want to REACH the lost, DISCIPLE believers, and SERVE all people. This booklet will help you understand! He continues on throughout, throwing out the word true over and over again. Act more." But what if the Christian life was truly meant to be "easy" and "light" just as Christ told us? He has been a frequent writer for the Church's publications, and has trained many ministers over the years. This course is based on Herbert Armstrongs Ambassador College Bible Correspondence Course where the reader would look up certain scriptures which were furnished (usually taken out of context) so they would come to the conclusions the WCG wanted them to. are registered trademarks of Newsmax Media, Inc. Newsmax TV, and Newsmax World are trademarks of Newsmax Media, Inc. The Assemblies of God were founded in Hot Springs, Arkansas in April, 1914. It is not specific medical advice for any individual. Pastor Chuck Swindoll points out that the church is really the body of Christ. Religion tells us, "Do more. The Church of God believes "that all have sinned and come short of the glory of God and that repentance is commanded of God for all and necessary for forgiveness of sins," according to ChurchofGod.org, and that "justification, regeneration, and the new birth are wrought by faith in the blood of Jesus Christ." 2. The Church of God has a congregational system of church government, and ministers belong to state and regional assemblies. Top headlines for Thursday, February 23, 2023 The Southern Baptist Convention has decided to cut ties with Saddleback Church, one of the largest churches in the United States, and four other churches over their decision to elevate women to the office of pastor. If a religious group had exactly equal shares of each of the five racial and ethnic groups (20% each), it would get a 10.0 on the index; a religious group made up entirely of one racial group would get a 0.0. God is one, composed of spirit and comprising a family presently consisting of God the Father and Jesus Christ the Son. According to one congregant, he "left in a huff" as the evangelist on the video asserted that people's problems were of their own . We believe that the Bible is the inspired and infallible word of God and it is the standard instruction for living life. CHURCH OF GOD IS - Church Of God Beliefs, The Church of God was founded in 1886 upon the principles of Christ as they are revealed in the Bible, the Word of God. The Living Church of God (LCG) was founded in 1998 by Presiding Evangelist Roderick C. Meredith and is based in North Carolina. However, LCG believes that in order to be considered a Philadelphian, individual members must do their part, and must not allow their lives to be cluttered by the cares of this world so that they themselves become lukewarm (Laodicean) (Living Church News, Jul-Aug 2001, What is a Philadelphian? by Robert Thiel, p.15). With a diverse ministry and membership on six continents, thousands of Living Churchof God members gather regularly for weekly Sabbath services and annual convocations. It has its foundation of faith and practice in the Scriptures and the vital experience of its constituents is scriptural oriented. The LCG views the central message of the Bible to be the Gospel of Christ, the "Good News" of the coming of the Kingdom of God, as well as the forgiveness of sins through the sacrifice of Jesus Christ. The Church Of The Living God Is A Church That Believes In Jesus, And A Church That Loves God And People. We are zealous to meet with all lovers of truth and would love to hear from you! [10], Shortly after LCG's incorporation, it started producing a weekly, half-hour television program: Tomorrow's World. What is the Living Church of God, and what are their beliefs? The sight of the saints of God has never failed to bring relief to a fellow pilgrim. Ratzmann killed eight, including his pastor, his pastor's son, and himself. [9] The members should not tithe on "unearned income" (such as Social Security, old-age assistance, unemployment benefits, pensions, gifts, disability, or similar types of income). When Jesus Christ founded His church in 31ad, He gave it a mission: To preach the Gospel of the Kingdom of God to all nations and to make disciples. Wheelchair Accessible. What denomination are you? Meredith stated that LCG is carrying on the teachings of Herbert W. Armstrong more than any other group on earth.5 Similar authoritarian groups say the same thing. Gerald Weston, a minister in the Living Church of God, gave a sermon in November that caught the attention of many in his congregation LCG. 5,7,8) 4 LCG Official Statement of Fundamental Beliefs/Church History 5 All or Nothing Statement by Roderick C. Meredith. Newsmax, Moneynews, Newsmax Health, and Independent. God is calling you to come out. The largest denomination with this name is the Church of God (Cleveland, Tennessee), Last edited on 18 February 2023, at 18:02, Church of God International (United States), Church of God Preparing for the Kingdom of God, Churches of God General Conference (Winebrenner), Church of God of the Original Mountain Assembly, The Church of God (Charleston, Tennessee), The Church of God, Alexander Jackson Sr. General Overseer, Original Church of God or Sanctified Church, Fire Baptized Holiness Church of God of the Americas, New Testament Christian Churches of America, The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Church_of_God&oldid=1140146647, Church of God, a Worldwide Association, separated from, The Churches of God in the Fellowship of the Son of God, the Lord Jesus Christ, also known as, This page was last edited on 18 February 2023, at 18:02. In November 1998, Meredith was fired from Global Church of God after an authority conflict. Meredith had felt he should be the unquestionable leader.2 In December of that year, he founded Living Church of God (LCG) in San Diego, California. (Read: The Law of Moses and the Grace of God). On December 20, 1952, after summoning him back to the WCG's headquarters in Pasadena, California, from his pastorship in Oregon, Armstrong ordained him and four other men including his uncle Dr. C. Paul Meredith to the position of Evangelist. 704-844-1970[emailprotected]. Our television broadcast and bi-monthly magazine can be viewed at www.tomorrowsworld.org. Congregants of this church simply identify themselves as Christians, without using denominational identification. We believe that it is by Him that God created all things and that without Him was not anything made that was made. The Living Church of God(Living) and the United Church of God, an International Association (United) both had their roots in the Worldwide Church of God. Bob Thiel said he no longer believes LCG is the Philadelphia remnant in Revelation 3 and that CCOG is now leading the final phase of the work. In 2018 CCG was reported to have 3,800 members (3,600 in Africa). The Tomorrows World telecast is sponsored by the Living Church of God. January-February 2022. All information presented on our websites should not be construed as medical consultation or instruction. Church of the Living God exists to reach and influence the world by building a large Christ-centered, Bible-based church, changing mindsets . and there is a video on their site from August 2013 entitled, Where is Gods True Church?. In 2016, after consultation with the Council of Elders, many friends and fellow ministers, Dr. Meredith appointed Evangelist Gerald Weston as his successor and as president of the Living Church of God. We trace our roots back to the first-century Church of God established by Jesus Christ, and we hold fast to the teachings and practices of Christ and the apostles. god is . On February 26, 2005, the shooter, a lifelong member of the Worldwide Church of God and its offshoot, the Living Church of God, got up and left the Sabbath service in the middle of a recorded sermon. Although U.S. Jews (90% white) and Hindus (91% Asian) are not very diverse, especially compared with Americans overall, the five least diverse groups in the index are all Protestant denominations. Unlike most Protestant sects, the LCG observes the annual festivals outlined in the Old Testament, citing the biblical instruction that these special days be celebrated "forever" (Leviticus 23:14). Polity: Non . The LCG considers itself engaged in a three-fold mission. Greetings from Charlotte, Mr. and Mrs. Gerald Weston, Mr. Mario Hernandez, and Mr. Cristian Orrego are in Medellin, Colombia, for a regional conference for Due to declining health, in 2016 (aged 86), Meredith appointed Evangelist Gerald E. Weston as his successor and as President of LCG. The LCG is one of more than 200 splinter churches that have split from the WCG. approximately 320 programs have been taped and televised. A Sore Point. [5] The church reported in 2011 that it had 330 congregations in 45 countries, and that over 8,000 members attended its annual eight-day festival of the Feast of Tabernacles and Last Great Day, at 46 sites in 31 countries on every continent (except Antarctica). If you are a former member of LCG, we hope you will find our material helpful. The goal isn't just to learn about the love of God, it's to experience it in its entirety.
Hot Pink Jeep Wrangler For Sale,
Ransom Eric And Maxine Relationship,
Articles W
You must 23 legal defenses to foreclosure to post a comment.