ringu vs the ring reddit

I also have yet to read the Ringu manga that's been out for a bit, but I plan on giving that a look, too. To see the original after the bigger budget remake could be seen as a step back. The changes made to The Ring were good in localizing the material and the backstory, making them more relatable to an English speaking viewer, not just translating things directly. Perf. In the American version of the opening scene, we cut back and forth between an empty room and her face, which breaks the tension. [–]SiddharthaSuburbia 12 points13 points14 points 1 month ago (2 children). Those themes are all there in the remake but it swaps the creepy mundanity for hype and more traditional horror tropes. Never cared for the negative flashes throughout the film. P.S. Ringu (1998) Plot. Enjoy! [–]Bardiyo 2 points3 points4 points 1 month ago (0 children). I dunno why I always thought the US version mixed parts 1 and 2. The way everything is shot in the Japanese version is just so... normal, which helps create a sense of the uncanny. [–]Horrorfan5 2 points3 points4 points 1 month ago (2 children), [–]TheArtyDans 1 point2 points3 points 1 month ago (1 child). In the American version you have a comfortable, well-understood technology that has been invaded by a vengeful spirit that nobody understands. Of course, I think that Ringu's scary scenes are scarier than The Ring's. I haven't seen The Ring 2, and from what I've heard that's more blessing than curse. I am sure the horse scene was from Part 2...or not!! [–]TheArtyDans 2 points3 points4 points 1 month ago (3 children). [–]EpsilonX 7 points8 points9 points 1 month ago (0 children). I have watched tons of Asian cinema, particularly J-Horror, and I was still surprised just how entrenched in the culture some elements of Ringu were. triangular relationship Ringu Koji Suzuki (published 1991) Ringu Hideo Nakata Gore Verbinski (released 1998) (released 2002) Remaking film Remaking and Adaptation typology The Ring Types of remakes: the acknowledged, close remake the acknowledged, transformed remake the I understand that this is probably a little nitpicky, but it did have a small effect on my enjoyment of the film. I have not seen either of these movies. But I still prefer Ringu. Is it worth sitting through the series or is it better to just see the movie? I’m a bit late to this, and there’s some great comments here already, but I’d like to add that I think it depends on what one you saw first. Presented by Cevetta for JPN369 In my analysis I am comparing the movie Ringu and how it incorporates its values from Japanese society, to its American counterpart The Ring and it's own portrayal of values. We are anchored with her and in the moment. Gore Verbinski. Ringu. In that aspect this moment was more impactful. They're both very good, but I prefer the original. I love the stripped-down, creepy ambience, and the quiet tension between the characters. Having read the original book, the story is meant to be a mystery thriller until the end anyways. I still think the reveal in Ringu is the best monster/ghost/villain reveal I've ever seen. The fear in RINGU comes from skin-deep slow burn. The American version looks and behaves like a dated music video. This allows Ringu to be far more unsettling for me because there is no reprieve. They are both pretty good but in their own ways. I agree with most your points. The Ring, on the other hand, is one of my favorite horror films of all time. In a filmmaking aspect I prefer Ringu, I love how it’s shot and prefer the acting as well. I was thinking of watching "The Ring" until I found out that it's actually … [–]Hermione_Jean_Okiku Doll 3 points4 points5 points 1 month ago (0 children), [–]Fanboy375 4 points5 points6 points 1 month ago (0 children). I’m genuinely surprised by how good the Remake was, especially considering how American Remake of The Grudge turned out.. oof. [–]Kamino_Neko 4 points5 points6 points 1 month ago (0 children). The creepy footage on the video is typical nu-metal music video stuff that was common at the time, even has similar edits. You might also enjoy 'Maribito', which was his homage to Lovecraft. All subtlety or nuance is thrown completely out the fuckin' window. I liked the atmosphere that Japanese version made.And the character development it showed. It's characters seem more fleshed out and it's story is portrayed more clearly than Ringu's. I wouldn't slap a child, but just look at that stupid bitchass face. On a plot basis and overall enjoyment I gotta give it to The Ring(U.S.). Twin brother Hans refused to marry her The couple had opened a coffee Everything is blue, everything is "scary". The Ring is a great americanized popcorn horror movie. It's just one scene, but it was a scene worth making a video for. The Ring definitely has more scares pound for pound, but I'll take the atmosphere of the original. In both versions of the film, The Ring/Ringu the story is told as a personal haunting experience, using mundane like objects such as television sets, phones, and computers, instilling a sense of uncertainty.Successful in both Japan and North America, techo-fear is a cross-cultural form of communicating the horror behind technology. But the worst aspects were the ridiculous makeup on Curse!Samara and her victims, and that they made Samara a damn child. The premise of this page is to identify how the three different versions of the Ring myth (namely: Ringu and its sequels, The Ring Virus and the US remake The Ring) compare visually. Considering that Ringu, the 1998 Japanese film, sparked a … By using our Services, you agree to our use of cookies.Learn More. The film was first teased as an April Fools' joke on April 1, 2015, but was later confirmed on December 10, 2015, to be a real production. This films version of the final scene had some superb sfx and camera movement. Even at the time of its release it felt hokey. The film-making aspect goes a long way with me. I disagree, but I perfectly understand where you're coming from. The Ring is one of the very few remakes that's arguably better than the original. Remakes. Now I can't even remember if USA part 2 follows Japanese part 2... [–]Horrorfan5 2 points3 points4 points 1 month ago (0 children), It kinda did. Honestly it's the best J-Horror movie ever made, and one of the best Horror movies overall. Use of this site constitutes acceptance of our User Agreement and Privacy Policy. and join one of thousands of communities. The early 2000s J-horror craze is largely attributed to the … The latter...1) spooky children are such a cliche, and I'm basically over it. Making everything blue is neither good cinematography nor good color work. I can't comment whether or not it's a good adaptation of the novel because I haven't read it yet unfortunately. It makes some positive changes (notably, there's some...very iffy science in the novel that the movie is better for ignoring). Which brings us to the infamous RINGU vs. Ringu cuts through “the glass screen” and in doing so it also breaks an unspoken pact with the viewer, one we didn’t necessarily even know we had made. I also threw in one scene from Hideo Nakata's Ringu 2 (1999). 2) I'm even more over people assuming Sadako, and even Kayako, and other onryo characters are, as well. And in the Japanese the cursed tape was creeepier too, When i first saw Ring it was on TV i was like 14-16 and i really liked it,then many years later i watched the original japanese and i was like damn this is the atmosphere i want in movies like this imo it is better done then the american one, [–]dread1961 2 points3 points4 points 1 month ago (0 children). First we have Japan, THE Cult (2013) is top-tier found footage horror! Addressing the hot topic of which is better: The Original, or the remake? Slower, not many scares, duller, I get it. I can't comment whether or not it's a good adaptation of the novel because I haven't read it yet unfortunately. [–]SiddharthaSuburbia 9 points10 points11 points 1 month ago* (1 child). Oops, [–]thewhitecat55 -1 points0 points1 point 1 month ago (2 children). I just think the girl being found in the closet is scarier than the flash into negative, but in all other respects the Japanese version is superior. Washed out look. Either way both are good and well made. It’s a vastly superior film in every single way, and I will die on this hill (though I respect your reasons for preferring the remake). The original Japanese film Ringu wasn't the first appearance of a spooky girl and her cursed videotape. [–]Horrorfan5 1 point2 points3 points 1 month ago (0 children), I prefer the American version But they’re pretty interchangeable to me, [–]Rainbow- 1 point2 points3 points 1 month ago (0 children). All the actors play their parts well. The film-making aspect goes a long way with me. I love both Ringu and The Ring, for completely different reasons. But I still prefer Ringu. That said, Ringu wasn’t really scary at all because it was a supernatural mystery. The added moments of tension really made me enjoy it more. REDDIT and the ALIEN Logo are registered trademarks of reddit inc. π Rendered by PID 23686 on r2-app-0cbf9e51885554a89 at 2021-03-17 17:42:52.302469+00:00 running 5c075df country code: LT. Get an ad-free experience with special benefits, and directly support Reddit. It's fucking fantastic. I haven't seen any of the Ringu sequels either, either than Ring 0: Happy Birthday, and that was more weird drama with a little bit of horror at the end. Next is to watch both of the Sequels. It's as if the technological world is slowly destroying the people it is meant to serve and no amount of modern tech can protect us from primeval evil. ), [–]Nurokatt 2 points3 points4 points 1 month ago (0 children). Yeah another person who thinks in Ring the color was a bit weird,felt fake,the Japanese don't play with it and it felt more real. In honor of our new weekly "Supernatural Saturdays" and it may be a little late, but MonstersOfMidian decided to do a topic on the Japanese supernatural thriller Ringu and it's Americanized remake that came out in 2002 The Ring. Ringu Year released: 1998 Directed by: Hideo Nakata Starring: a bunch of Japanese people whose names I can't pronounce. I am a fan of the notion of building this movie up and up until it finally shows you Sadako come out of the TV. [–]The_Hero_Finn 12 points13 points14 points 1 month ago (3 children). For this film set review, I had several ideas about which direction I wanted to focus on for the two horror films. It’s almost a necessity that I touch on the American remake, The Ring. I will agree here, for sure. Ringu plays with the idea of horror within the mundane and normal. I like both of them, but once it gets into the sequels the Japanese ones are much better. [–]Kamino_Neko 6 points7 points8 points 1 month ago (0 children). If you are looking for jumps, watch the American remake instead. Ringu was such an influential horror movie for its time that it effectively kicked off a surge of original J-Horror that continues to this day, over 20 years after its release. The US remakes of Japanese horror are more about the reaction of Westerners to an alien foreign culture. [–]Devilloc YÅ«rei 8 points9 points10 points 1 month ago (1 child), Better cinematography , better color work. Ironic considering a certain plot device, but we’ll get to that later. In Ringu, you have a pretty well understood, traditional ghost that has horrifically used modern technology to avenge itself. American version is shite in my opinion, except for the opening scene which is better in the American one. I couldn't even finish the American version...it's been so long since I've tried to watch it that I can't remember everything that annoyed me about it, though I do remember the last straw was a scene with a horse freaking out (not that I any longer have any idea why it annoyed me). They were never going to go far enough. [–]wagamamalullaby 2 points3 points4 points 1 month ago (0 children). I was engrossed into the mystery but it was kinda disappointing that it didn’t really have any moments of terror until the final moments(which is very effective and well constructed). I think the horror factor comes from different cultural contexts in some ways. It was different from anything I had ever seen before, especially the shocking climax. Better cinematography , better color work , better actors. Meanwhile, The Ring is horror all the way. For me Ringu was much better,had that unease atmosphere almost the entire movie,and it felt nicer. Original Vs Remake: Ringu vs The Ring. Isn't the American version actually a mixture of parts 1 and 2? However I think the book is way better than either movie and I'd really enjoy getting a closer adaptation of it. 12 votes, 26 comments. Rendered by PID 23686 on r2-app-0cbf9e51885554a89 at 2021-03-17 17:42:52.302469+00:00 running 5c075df country code: LT. The Ring definitely has more scares pound for pound, but I'll take the atmosphere of the original. Sadako vs. Kayako (貞子 vs 伽椰子, Sadako bāsasu Kayako) is a 2016 Japanese supernatural horror film directed by Kōji Shiraishi.It is a crossover of the Ju-on and the Ring series. The Ring, a 2002 American re-make of a Japanese film called Ringu, is a wonderfully disquieting film.I’ve seen literally hundreds of horror movies, and I was genuinely creeped out at the end of this one. Edit: just realized your post is 12 days old. The visuals look great. !? I recall in an interview he once did, he really wanted to work in Hollywood with larger budgets and American fans. Does anyone know where to watch eko eko azarak ii birth of the wizard(1996). Guinea Pig 3, 4, and 5 original Japanese VHS tapes, Ring Kanzenban - broadcast and video comparison, My Ringu/Sadako collection (with bonus cat). I personally feel that that washed out neutral palette added to the feel of the film. That is what I think , and still is. It follows the template but also has its own identity. I can see why many consider the original to be inferior to it, as it’s a more visceral, exciting film, full of scares throughout, as that’s more appealing to the western market. As much as I've bashed The Ring in this post, I feel that overall it is a better film than Ringu. [–]Bardiyo 4 points5 points6 points 1 month ago* (0 children). The good: It's a good film in its own right, and seems to understand what made the novel work and gets as close to doing the same thing as a film can (it's not a particularly cinematic novel). The cinematography is beautiful. [–]The_Hero_Finn 7 points8 points9 points 1 month ago (1 child). RING/U Does America just suck at horror movies? From Ring (Ringu) to Rings and Sadako to Samara. Pen name Karen Blixen Born in Rungstedlun, Denmark in 1885 Grew up in a aristocratic home Frequently wrote when she was little Father passed away at age 10 Married Swedish cousin Baron Bror von Blixen-Finecke. [–]SiddharthaSuburbia 4 points5 points6 points 1 month ago (0 children). In Ringu… Obviously there's slight differences in the plots, which is beyond the remit of this page. Ringu is a good film, but it's not a personal favorite of mine. [–]nicolao_merlao 6 points7 points8 points 1 month ago (1 child). And the final scene is a million times better in the Japanese one. In fact, it's an adaptation of a 1991 Japanese novel by Koji Suzuki, the first in a series of six. Has anyone seen the Tokyo Vampire Hotel, the movie or the mini-series? The spirit is what makes the technology uncontrollable. Showing all 5 items Jump to: Summaries (4) Synopsis (1) Summaries. The uncle dies similar to Samara’s dad, [–]Blackcat1206 2 points3 points4 points 1 month ago (0 children), Ringu is the film that made me full in love with world horror (especially Japanese) when I was a snot-nosed kid; so you'd expect me to say I prefer Ringu, and I do but apart from big-time nostalgia for this film, in my personal opinion it's a real shitter and as fantastic photography, as well as an eerie dream-like atmosphere which isn't present in the American version although that version does have some great points and maybe as in my experience, may inspire young or new people who love the American version to watch Ringu (my Cousin's kids were watching it with me and I told them of the original, and now they love the original too! Though it bears more similarities to the Japanese film than to the novel, it’s essentially a copy of a copy. It's much more believable, in fact for most of the movie you're not quite sure if the supernatural even exists. Personally, I found Ringu to be… [–]dethb0y 3 points4 points5 points 1 month ago (0 children). I do love both of these films however, and I would love to know what the sub thinks about both of them. [–]ivanalexey 1 point2 points3 points 1 month ago (0 children), Agree fully. Naomi Watts is great ofc, but goddamn the kid who plays Aidan is annoying as all fucking hell. For me, the originality of the Japanese one made it unforgettable; it was both a thriller and a mystery, mysterious and otherworldly, while the remake just felt like a ‘horror film’ to me. I honestly don't really consider the two particularly comparable due to the differences in style and tone. Maybe it's been too long but I remember Ringu being more of a 'mystery thriller' and the ending was horror. More generic horror stuff thrown in. For a Remake I really liked how it attempted to improve upon the original. All he can say is: "She gave me the goldfish" or "She gave me the ring back to me 'Is he mad with love of a girl, or because he saw or committed some terrible crime.'' The American version suffered from needing to fit the ridiculous PG13 rating they wanted so they could maximise tickets. [–]Devilloc YÅ«rei 3 points4 points5 points 1 month ago (1 child). My point here isn't that Ringu isn't horror (because it is) but it's that The Ring is what the majority of people expect when they want to watch a horror flick. I like the remake though, don’t get me wrong. It’s something I’ve always been adamantly against. But I would rewatch the original every time instead. The Son character was also better done in this version imo. © 2021 reddit inc. All rights reserved. Obviously Ringu is a better “film”, but I was entertained 10x more by the Remake. Anatomia Extinction, short prequel to Tokyo Gore Police, is getting a limited BluRay release. I love both of these films, so I would take that as a warning that this will probably be a long post. The remake is more sleek and polished, but it relied a bit more on spectacle while the original was more subtle, nuanced and wholly developed. Horses go mad, for some reason. I found Ringu to be the scarier of the two but I think The Ring is more interesting visually, more emotional, and, by putting a greater focus on the mystery rather than the horror, flows better. It was a good movie, but ttat ruined it for me. I like the American Remake more because it actually tries to be scary and the scares aren’t very schlocky either. I agree with all your points. I thought the American Remake was much better. except for the opening scene which is better in the American one. Cookies help us deliver our Services. The 2002 remake had more technological resources and a stronger desire to freak out the audience. The avoidable negative: It makes one change that was unnecessary, and necessitated focus on it that could have been given to some of the stuff that they cut (Ryuji and Reiko's relationship). Visual comparison of Hideo Nakata's "Ringu" and Kim Dong-bin's remake "The Ring Virus". I saw Rasen... that’s it, nothing else to say there. The first because it's just gilding the damn lily. In the Japanese we hold on a wide shot behind the girl for a bit, which builds tension and creates a sense of perspective. That's why I think there's a big divide between fans. One curse, one cure, one week to find it. Visual comparison between Hideo Nakata's Ringu (1998) and Gore Verbinski's The Ring (2002). Ringu (Japanese film, 1998), directed by Hideo Nakata. For example, the VHS tape in Ringu is scarier to me because the imagery featured in it is just... bizarre, and although it is explained, it doesn't change the impact of the footage. The US remake WAS better. In Ring the colors were a bit wierd too,too blueish grey. Too in-your-face with its scares, louder and more jump scares. I really enjoyed Ringu for it’s building suspense and the false ending was fantastic. Dir. Another reason why I personally prefer Ringu is due to the fact that The Ring seems to be dowsed in an odd bluish tinge for many of its scenes (especially the scenes set in the city). I thought he US remake of Ringu was worse. Idk, I guess the reason for my preference is because it’s been tailor-made for American tastes. It's certainly a good adaptation as far as american remakes go, but it doesn't hold a candle to the original IMO. I encourage all of you who enjoy intelligent horror/suspense films to check this one out if … Let me explain: Since I'm not Japanese, I am more familiar with American culture, which allows a viewer like me a little comfort, as there is a small piece of familiarity. [–]Harley2280 3 points4 points5 points 1 month ago (0 children). THE RING internet battle: A pointless one. The technology is what makes the ghost uncontrollable. I’m excited. I'm going to have to politely disagree with this. I was lucky to see the Japanese one first, and experienced the slow build, gripping tension. Ringu vs The Ring I recently re-watched both The Ring and Ringu and find myself thinking, for the first time ever, that The Ring is the better of the two. Complementary Video to Ringu/The Ring Virus/The Rings Side-by-Side (https://youtu.be/5mhR_o42O_s). Blah. Ringu's characters are not quite as fleshed out, and I honestly prefer several aspects of The Ring to Ringu. The Ring relies on some really bad tropes, that others have talked about here (the color grading is particularly bad) but I find it a much scarier movie - it does a great job of keeping you creeped out the entire time. In other ways it’s just overblown and ridiculous, horse bit on the boat just thrown in to wake people up. There's nuance and some things are open for interpretation. Dir. The American remake seems like its tape is meant to scare the viewer through shock value, which is less effective (in my opinion). I love the stripped-down, creepy ambience, and the quiet tension between the characters. Great review, thanks for posting.The Japanese and US versions were written and directed by the same guy, Takashi Shimizu. What are your favourite and least favourite Sion Sono works. For most people, it was the flashier, more overtly scary remake. The neutral: It made some changes from the novel that weren't necessary, but also didn't negatively impact things (Asakawa's gender and marital status, frex). [–]thewhitecat55 -1 points0 points1 point 1 month ago (0 children). Marta talks about his I also really dislike the son in The Ring, and the heavy blue filter is an eye-sore imo. Both films are different in their own way, but they are also very similar. In Asian culture, Ringu is scarier and it flows better, and in American culture The Ring is scarier and it flows better. I noticed distinct differences between the two in physical characteristics,… I enjoyed both immensely. Ultimately, what stood out to me the most about was how the original character Sadako in Ringu compared to Samara in The Ring. Visual comparison between Hideo Nakata's Ringu 2 (1999) and The Ring (2005). It's fun to watch, it's what people would more easily call a "scary movie", but it lost the spark that made Ringu the absolutely genius film that it is. Sorry you didn't enjoy the US version as much, but it helps me to think of them all being in the same universe as a growing threat to the world, like they did with The Ring. use the following search parameters to narrow your results: A place to celebrate and discuss Japanese horror movies! Edit: I must clarify. A reporter and her ex-husband investigate a cursed video tape that is rumored to … The Ring 1-Rafael is a poor fisherman who, for some reason, in the past, went crazy. It was only months after I sat, utterly unimpressed in the theater, watching The Ring that I learned that it had been a remake of a Japanese movie called Ringu, which I then made it my mission to see.For whatever reason, it wasn't easy to find back then. I like the Japanese and American versions. I understand why a lot of people say that Ringu is "more of a thriller". Naomi Watts, Martin Henderson, Brin Cox, and Deveign Chase. [–]Bout0067 7 points8 points9 points 1 month ago (0 children). Director Hideo Nakata’s 1998 Japanese horror film Ringu was so popular when it released that it launched an entire franchise that includes numerous sequels, prequels, and American remakes. Fake ass color grading, obnoxious over the top sound design, and goofy "creature" design... Also, that terrible thing studio movies love to do where they constantly cut to reaction or POV shots instead of lingering or holding, which of course breaks up the tension. r/thering: A subreddit for fans of the Japanese horror (J-Horror) series Ring by Koji Suzuki. Dreamworks Pictures, 2002. Honestly, I think that although both of these films are absolutely fantastic, I prefer Ringu, but I think The Ring is an objectively better film. Ringu is widely known for featuring the disturbing VHS tape that places a curse on the viewer which will kill them in just seven days. Ringu vs The Ring(U.S.)Review (self.J_Horror). I also really dislike the son in The Ring, and the heavy blue filter is an eye-sore imo. read the book. Film. It's subdued, incredibly... "Mundane" I guess is the word. I also loved the reinvention of Sadako’s(Samara’s) origin was quite interesting and justified her intent. If you don't agree , that is fine. What is your favourite J-Horror franchise? Lots of tryhard weebs in this thread :/, [–]pitch- 0 points1 point2 points 24 days ago (0 children). The unavoidable negative: It necessarily jettisoned a lot of the novel (both because of the 'not super cinematic' aspect, and the 'we have just over an hour to work with' aspect), and some of that made the story a bit flatter, since we don't learn nearly as much about Sadako. The extra parts(like pulling the hair) kept my attention. Ringu is overall a better movie IMO. A random psychic chick crawling out of the cursed person's TV and inducing a heart attack isn't scary enough, she has to be monstrously ugly and cause her victims to be deformed, too? References The Ring. As an adaptation, it's about the middle of the road, IMO. Sure, some tense parts but actual scary moments throughout the film were just not there for me.

Instyle Magazine Cover Obama, Don Dunstan Wikipedia, Nomadland Amazon Prime, Overwatch Orange Symbols, Hindmarsh Shire Map, Fortnite Sniper Nerf Gun, Orb Naturality Discogs, Chagatai Khan Mochi Yebe, Dream11 Offer Amazon, Hollick The Bard,